Clergy in the Decameron: Another Look?
Janet Levarie Smarr — Heliotropia, Vol. 11 (2014)
Download PDF, 0.08 MB | Open PDF in New Tab ↗
Abstract
This article reassesses the portrayal of ecclesiastical figures in Giovanni Boccaccio’s Decameron by shifting critical focus from social hierarchy—previously examined by Cormac Ó Cuilleanáin—to moral agency. While acknowledging that lustful, greedy, or fraudulent clerics dominate the collection’s comic plots, Janet Levarie Smarr demonstrates that Boccaccio deliberately balances erring ecclesiastics with dutiful, virtuous counterparts across nearly every rank of the Church, from popes (such as Boniface VIII in X.2 and Alexander III in II.3) and the self-correcting Abbot of Cluny (I.7 and X.2) to local bishops (VIII.4), devout friars (I.1 and III.3), chaste nuns (Andreuola in IV.6), prudent hermits (III.10), and conscientious parish priests during the plague (I.Intro). By pairing negative examples with positive counter-examples, Boccaccio shows that clerical misconduct stems from individual moral choice rather than institutional inevitability or irresistible natural impulses. Ultimately, Smarr argues that these virtuous clerics fulfill Boccaccio’s stated ethical aim of illustrating both vices to avoid and virtues to imitate, reinforcing human moral responsibility and culminating in a structural 9+1 pattern that exempts Fiammetta from telling anticlerical tales.
Sommario
Questo articolo riesamina la rappresentazione del clero nel Decameron di Giovanni Boccaccio spostando l’attenzione critica dalla gerarchia sociale — già indagata da Cormac Ó Cuilleanáin — alla responsabilità morale. Pur riconoscendo che ecclesiastici lussuriosi, avari o fraudolenti animano gran parte delle trame comiche, Janet Levarie Smarr dimostra che Boccaccio affianca deliberatamente ai religiosi corrotti figure esemplari e virtuose quasi a ogni livello della gerarchia ecclesiastica: dai papi (Bonifacio VIII in X.2 e Alessandro III in II.3) e dall’abate di Clignì capace di ravvedersi (I.7 e X.2), fino ai vescovi (VIII.4), ai frati devoti (I.1 e III.3), alle monache oneste (Andreuola in IV.6), agli eremiti prudenti (III.10) e ai preti che assistono i moribondi durante la peste (I.Intro). Contrapporre modelli positivi agli esempi negativi permette a Boccaccio di ricondurre la corruzione clericale a una libera scelta individuale anziché a un destino istituzionale o naturale, confermando l’intento etico dell’opera ed evidenziando uno schema strutturale 9+1 che esenta Fiammetta dalle novelle anticlericali.